BOOK REVIEW
Gitlin's 'Unlimited' examines life in a world of media glut
By Jerry Ackerman, Globe Correspondent, 5/24/2002
Maybe you are listening to the radio while reading this. Maybe there's a
television on nearby or you are killing time waiting for your e-mail to
download. (Or maybe you are among the many people who ''watch'' TV, scan the
newspaper headlines, and go on the Internet all at the same time. No kidding.)
As for me, I began reading Todd Gitlin's ''Media Unlimited'' at an airport, and
there are few better places to drive home his point that our lives indeed are
awash in auditory and visual clutter.
While flight departure announcements blared from one overhead speaker, CNN
droned from another; the gate area was flanked by neon-lighted storefronts
hawking snacks, books, and trinkets to take home; and, of course, cellphones
were buzzing everywhere. As Gitlin puts it, the swirl of sounds and images that
surrounds us almost every minute of the day has ceased to be ''an accompaniment
to life'' and become ''a central experience of life.'' This isn't exactly news,
of course, except to the occasional hermit or cloistered monk.
What Gitlin's book adds is perspective on why this has come to be and some
thoughts about why we put up with it. The short answer, covering both points, is
that in a world where most work and home life can be pretty humdrum,
satisfaction has taken a high priority in our personal lives. Just in time, we
also came into an age where technology can help feed and nourish us when we are
feeling ennui. In addition to print and all its manifestations, from magazines
for any taste to T-shirt logos to ads wrapped around buses and taxis or
projected with spotlights on public sidewalks, the list rolls on: ubiquitous
radios, remote-accessible answering machines, fax machines, cellphones, laptop
computers, portable tape and CD players, beepers, Palm Pilots, the Internet,
PCDs, and GPDs.
The result is that entertainments that had been once-in-a-lifetime experiences
and within reach of only the rich are now considered entitlements, ever
available to massage us through our boredom. Where a theater ticket 200 years
ago cost roughly a day's pay for an average laborer, the cost today of watching
a cable-TV show at home can be calculated in pennies. Don't cast all the blame
on Disney or AOL Time Warner or Sony. The list of culprits begins before the
Middle Ages with wandering storytellers and minstrels. And if technology is to
be held at fault, one might as well start with Gutenberg's movable type, which
made spreading the printed word possible, and at lower cost than ever imagined.
We have only ourselves to blame for buying what's being sold, but the avalanche
we've helped create, in turn, has only further increased our expectations.
''Raised in the media torrent, most of us have come to expect - demand - nothing
less than its bounty,'' says Gitlin. ''Most people, most of the time, experience
media as signs of society's generosity. The profusion of images offers fun,
stimulus, feeling, or a sense of connection, however fugitive. We feel flattered
to have the access.''
And as any newspaper reader knows, trying to meet those expectations is big
business. Entertainment, providing content for all this technology to deliver,
is roughly an $80 billion industry. Philosophers, novelists, and songwriters get
a turn as Gitlin makes his case; Charles Dickens, Karl Marx, and Julia Roberts
have their day. Gitlin acknowledges that his recitations of history can be
tangled. But he also pulls nodding-off readers back with one-liners (''The
melange is the message'') and lists of ever more outrageous forms of media that
engulf us - such as ads in toilet stalls or posted above urinals. Gitlin, a New
York University journalism professor, despairs that democracy has benefited
little from the flood of information and entertainment that swamps our lives.
True, the media can mobilize populations when big issues arise. Witness the
buzz around water coolers and in supermarket aisles provoked by the O. J.
Simpson murder trial and Bill Clinton's White House peccadilloes, as well as the
massive contributions to charity and wholehearted political support that
followed the attacks of Sept. 11. In general, the torrent of information has
reduced civics to a sideshow, as marketers go for our emotional jugular by
hyping private lives and devaluing public affairs.
Participation in elections is at an all-time low. Gitlin holds little hope for
any real reversal. Indeed, he writes, ''if the argument of my book is even
approximately true, unlimited media are exactly what an urban-based, industrial
society with a money economy and a division of labor requires.'' So how do we
survive the onslaught? Easy question. In spite of mass media's best efforts,
we're not brain-dead. ''Everyone learns not only to see, but not to see - to
tune out and turn away,'' Gitlin notes. ''
We all learn to play favorites (and least favorites). What choice do we have?''
Media Unlimited: How the Torrent of Images and Sounds Overwhelms Our Lives, by
Todd Gitlin (Metropolitan Books, 288 pp., $25)
This story ran on page D2 of the Boston Globe on 5/24/2002. © Copyright 2002
Globe Newspaper Company.